Professional regulations
What circumstances require a reprimand for an SMMM?
General information on written service contracts, e-birlik registration, termination and handover records; legal bases for the provisions on reprimands and unfair competition.
What penalty applies to written contracts and e-birlik registration?
Accepting work without a written service contract and failing to enter contracts into the e-birlik software within the specified period are listed as circumstances requiring a reprimand. The legal basis is Serbest Muhasebeci Mali Müşavirlik ve Yeminli Mali Müşavirlik Kanunu Disiplin Yönetmeliği’nin 6 ncı maddesinin (d) bendidir. As a practitioner, you consider these two obligations separately.
Disiplin Yönetmeliği m.6/d states that the registration period is the period set by the Union. When reading this provision, you treat concluding a written contract and entering it into the software as separate actions. Having a written contract and registering it within the specified period are addressed separately in the subparagraph. You do not add a number of days that the text does not specify.
A reprimand is written notification to a practitioner or trainee practitioner that they are at fault in their duties and conduct. The legal basis for this definition is Serbest Muhasebeci Mali Müşavirlik ve Yeminli Mali Müşavirlik Kanunu Disiplin Yönetmeliği’nin 6 ncı maddesidir. Here you read about the scope of the provision; this explanation does not contain a disciplinary decision on an individual case.
Which provisions apply to termination and the return of documents?
If a contract is terminated for just cause or by mutual consent, the books and documents received are returned to their owners within one month, with a handover record drawn up. The legal basis is Serbest Muhasebeci Mali Müşavir ve Yeminli Mali Müşavirlerin Çalışma Usul ve Esasları Hakkında Yönetmelik’in 26 ncı maddesidir. You examine termination and the return of documents together.
-
Under what conditions can a contract be terminated?
The parties may terminate their contract at any time for just cause or by mutual consent. Yönetmelik m.26 lists non-payment of fees and the lack of sound and reliable documents provided to the practitioner as grounds for termination by the practitioner for just cause. You consider non-payment of fees within the framework of this termination provision.
The explanation of termination also addresses the parties’ rights to compensation; Yönetmelik m.26 makes these rights subject to general rules of law. This information is not a conclusion that compensation will be payable or that a particular amount will arise in a specific case. You read contract termination and the statement about compensation rights as separate matters.
-
When are books and documents returned?
Upon termination, the books and documents received are returned to their owners within one month, with a handover record drawn up. Yönetmelik m.26 specifies both the return period and the preparation of a record. As a practitioner, you draw up a handover record when returning these items; you assess the period according to the provision’s wording of one month.
Practitioners must keep the books and documents entrusted to them in good faith for as long as the work requires and return them when the work is complete. The legal basis is Serbest Muhasebeci Mali Müşavir ve Yeminli Mali Müşavirlerin Çalışma Usul ve Esasları Hakkında Yönetmelik’in 27 nci maddesidir. You read both the safekeeping of documents and their return upon completion of the work in conjunction with this provision.
-
What happens if the handover does not take place?
If the handover does not take place, the practitioner reports the situation to the professional chamber. Yönetmelik m.26 places this reporting obligation on the practitioner. You consider the failure to complete the handover and the reporting of that situation within the same provision. You read the explanation of reporting together with the rule on returning the books and documents received to their owners.
When reading the sequence of actions in this section, you distinguish between termination, the return of documents and reporting. Yönetmelik m.26 requires a handover record to be drawn up for the return within one month of termination; it specifies reporting to the chamber if the handover does not take place. You consider each explanation together with the condition set out for it in the article.
How do the provisions on reprimands and warnings for SMMM differ?
Warnings and reprimands are governed by separate articles in the disciplinary text. Serbest Muhasebeci Mali Müşavirlik ve Yeminli Mali Müşavirlik Kanunu Disiplin Yönetmeliği’nin 5 inci maddesi is devoted to the disciplinary penalty of a warning. Disiplin Yönetmeliği m.6 governs the disciplinary penalty of a reprimand. In the table below, you can see the acts listed in the subparagraph on written contracts and e-birlik registration.
Becoming a party to conflicts of interest in matters unrelated to professional duties falls under the heading of warnings. The legal basis is Serbest Muhasebeci Mali Müşavirlik ve Yeminli Mali Müşavirlik Kanunu Disiplin Yönetmeliği’nin 5 inci maddesinin (j) bendidir. When examining this subparagraph, you look at conduct in the course of professional practice. The condition in the provision is becoming a party to conflicts of interest in matters unrelated to professional duties.
| Act listed in the subparagraph | Disciplinary penalty | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| Accepting work without a written service contract | Reprimand | Disiplin Yönetmeliği m.6/d |
| Failure to enter professional service contracts into the e-birlik software within the period set by the Union | Reprimand | Disiplin Yönetmeliği m.6/d |
Which acts are listed for obtaining work through payments and benefits?
Acts and conduct that cause unfair competition in fees and financial practices are prohibited. The legal basis is SMMM ve YMM Mesleklerine İlişkin Haksız Rekabet ve Reklam Yasağı Yönetmeliği’nin 7 nci maddesidir. When reading this article, you consider the responsibility for professional solidarity together with the conduct listed in it.
Obtaining work by providing or promising payments or any benefit to third parties is among the acts considered unfair competition. The legal basis is SMMM ve YMM Mesleklerine İlişkin Haksız Rekabet ve Reklam Yasağı Yönetmeliği’nin 7 nci maddesinin (e) bendidir. This explanation shows the scope of the conduct listed in the article. When examining that conduct, you read the connection between the benefit provided or promised to a third party and obtaining work within the wording of the provision.
Obtaining work by promising or providing benefits to clients is also among the acts considered unfair competition. The legal basis is SMMM ve YMM Mesleklerine İlişkin Haksız Rekabet ve Reklam Yasağı Yönetmeliği’nin 7 nci maddesinin (f) bendidir. You consider conduct towards third parties and conduct towards clients under separate subparagraphs. These provisions fall under the heading of unfair competition in fees and financial practices.
Which rules apply to termination and contract registration?
The return of documents upon termination and the written contract and e-birlik registration when accepting new work are explained in separate provisions. For the return of documents, you consult Yönetmelik m.26–27 and, for the written contract and registration, Disiplin Yönetmeliği m.6/d . The answers below address these matters with their respective legal bases.